Has an MLS game ever ended 5-5?

Exactly once. On May 8, 2004, San Jose Earthquakes and New York Red Bulls drew 5-5, and no MLS game before or since has ended that way. When it happened it was a scorigami, the first 5-5 in league history.

Where 5-5 sits among nearby MLS scores. Deeper blue means a score has happened more often; the outlined cell is the new one.

That makes 5-5 the 31st most common final score out of 34 that have ever occurred in MLS. One point away, 6-5 has happened 3 times and 5-6 has happened never.

Every 5-5 in MLS history

Date	Teams	Season
2004-05-08	San Jose Earthquakes / New York Red Bulls	2004

Open the MLS grid at 5-5