Scorigami Center

The NHL has not had a new final score since 1993

By Scorigami Center · · 6 min read

On February 10, 1993, the Calgary Flames beat the San Jose Sharks 13-1. San Jose was in only its second season, and the game was a rout rather than a classic. It also turned out to be history. No NHL game had ended 13-1 before, and no NHL game has finished with a brand-new final score since. That is 33.7 years and 40,892 games, regular season and playoffs, without a single new square on the NHL grid.

Advertisement

Hockey is not low scoring in the soccer sense. Teams still put up five, six, seven goals on a regular basis. The NHL simply settled, long ago, into a set of results it keeps repeating, and the squares it has never filled all sit just past the point where modern teams stop scoring.

Ninety-five squares in 70,613 games

Since the league's first night in December 1917, the NHL has played 70,613 games and produced 95 distinct final scores. That works out to about 743 games for every score on the board. A handful of results do most of the work:

  • 3-2: 7,770 games, 11.0% of the total
  • 4-3: 5,802 games (8.2%)
  • 2-1: 5,397 games (7.6%)
  • 4-2: 4,934 games (7.0%)
  • 3-1: 4,441 games (6.3%)

At the other end, 14 scores have happened exactly once. 13-1 is one of them. So are Montreal's 16-3 over the Quebec Bulldogs on March 3, 1920, still the most goals any NHL winner has scored, and Detroit's 15-0 over the New York Rangers on January 23, 1944, the biggest margin in league history.

The first three seasons did most of the work

The NHL's opening night produced a 7-4 (Montreal Canadiens over Ottawa) and a 10-9 (Montreal Wanderers over the Toronto Arenas). The first season alone filled 27 of today's 95 squares. By the end of 1919-20, the league's third season, the count was 51. Those three seasons averaged 8.89 goals per game across just 133 games, a pace no later decade has matched.

Montreal's 14-7 win over the Toronto St. Patricks on January 10, 1920, is still tied for the highest-scoring game in league history at 21 goals. It shares the record with Edmonton's 12-9 win over Chicago on December 11, 1985.

Seasons startingGamesGoals per gameTiesNew scores
1917 to 19191338.890.8%51
1920s1,3784.6211.8%17
1930s2,1304.8015.2%4
1940s1,8556.2314.0%8
1950s2,2605.3017.4%1
1960s3,0575.8216.0%1
1970s7,1956.6215.3%5
1980s9,1547.6112.0%7
1990s10,7506.1112.1%1
2000s11,8495.565.3%0
2010s12,6465.630.0%0
2020s8,2066.190.0%0

The 1940s are the odd bump. Scoring climbed back to 6.23 goals a game, and the New York Rangers of the Second World War years took a beating: between November 1942 and March 1945 they conceded ten or more goals 15 times, including the 15-0 against Detroit, a 13-3 and a 14-3 against Boston, and a 10-9 loss to the Bruins.

The droughts before this one

The grid has gone quiet before, just never this long. After Toronto beat Chicago 12-4 on March 8, 1947, the NHL added exactly one new score in the next 21 years and change: Toronto's 14-1 over the Rangers on March 16, 1957. The gap from there to Chicago's 12-0 over Philadelphia on January 30, 1969, was 11.9 years, the longest in league history until now.

Then came the last great burst. The 1980s were the highest-scoring NHL decade since its first three seasons, at 7.61 goals a game, and they produced seven new scores. Buffalo beat Toronto 14-4 in March 1981. Minnesota beat Winnipeg 15-2 that November. Toronto beat Chicago 9-8 in October 1981, and Philadelphia beat Vancouver 13-2 in October 1984. Edmonton was involved in the other three: a 12-8 over Minnesota in January 1984, the 12-9 over Chicago, and an 11-9 loss to Toronto on January 8, 1986.

That 11-9 was followed by a 7.1-year wait for Calgary's 13-1. The current drought is now nearly three times as long as the previous record.

Ties, overtime and the shootout's extra goal

For most of its history the NHL let games end level. From 1917-18 through 2003-04, 5,754 of 43,186 games (13.3%) finished tied, with 2-2 the most common at 1,679. The 1950s were peak tie territory at 17.4%. The last ties came on April 4, 2004, the final day of 2003-04: the Islanders and Flyers drew 3-3, and Florida and Carolina drew 6-6.

After the 2004-05 season was lost, the league came back in 2005-06 with the shootout, and on this grid, as in the NHL's official scoring, a shootout win counts as one extra goal for the winner. A 2-2 game decided in a shootout goes down as 3-2. That is why 3-2 jumped from 9.7% of games in the 1983-84 to 2003-04 overtime era to 15.1% since 2005-06, and why one-goal games went from 31.4% to 44.5%.

The shootout also froze the diagonal for good. The NHL has had eight 8-8 ties, the last between New Jersey and Buffalo on January 15, 1992, but never a 9-9. Now it never will. A 9-9 game today would go into the books as 10-9, a score the league has already seen four times. A 10-10 game settled in a shootout, though, would produce a brand-new 11-10.

Where the 96th score will come from

Look at the edge of the filled grid and the gaps are oddly specific. 11-8 is boxed in on all four sides: 10-8, 12-8, 11-7 and 11-9 have all happened, but 11-8 never has. 12-6 and 12-7 are empty even though 12-8 and 12-9 exist. So is 13-5. And there has never been a 14-0, despite two 13-0 games and the 15-0 of 1944.

To put rough odds on those, we ran a simple model: each team's goals drawn independently from the league's scoring since 2015-16, an average of 3.00 per team per game, at about 1,400 games a season. It is crude, but it holds up on the high-scoring squares we can check. It expects 3.5 games of 10-1 over that span, and there were four.

Empty scoreChance in any one gameExpected wait
12-6about 1 in 181,000about 130 seasons
11-8about 1 in 282,000about 200 seasons
13-5about 1 in 392,000about 280 seasons
12-7about 1 in 424,000about 300 seasons
14-0about 1 in 3.7 millionabout 2,600 seasons

Even the likeliest candidate is, on these numbers, a once-a-century event. The real game has fatter tails than any model (empty-net goals, a goalie left in to take a beating), and a single 1980s-style season would change the math. But the league produces a ten-goal team in only about one game in a thousand these days, and every open square needs a winner with at least eleven. The closest recent brush was Seattle's 9-8 win over Los Angeles on November 29, 2022, a score the league has now seen five times.

The Olympic contrast

The men's Olympic tournament shows what hockey looks like without parity. In 891 games since 1920 it has produced 99 distinct final scores, more than the NHL, at roughly nine games per score. Canada beat Czechoslovakia 30-0 and then Switzerland 33-0 two days later in 1924, and the United States beat Italy 31-1 in 1948. The Olympic grid even holds a 14-0 and a 13-7, two scores the NHL has never managed.

Yet the Olympic men's grid has stalled too. Its last new score was the United States' 10-6 win over Austria on February 13, 1988, and ten tournaments have passed since without a new square. The women's tournament, which began in 1998, is still filling in: 41 scores in 180 games, the newest a 10-3 for Canada over Switzerland on February 14, 2022, though the 2026 tournament added nothing.

The NHL's grid is older and fuller than either. Somewhere out there is an 11-8 or a 12-6 waiting for a bad night between two leaky teams. It has been waiting since 1993.

Advertisement