The strangest final scores in NFL history
Football scores are supposed to be predictable. Touchdowns come in sevens, field goals come in threes, and across 18,139 NFL games since 1920 (counting the AFL's ten seasons, as our grid does) the final has landed on 20-17 a record 303 times. Yet the full NFL score grid holds 1,093 different final scores, and 255 of them have happened exactly once. Some are blowouts and some are shootouts. The strangest ones are tiny.
Why some numbers are awkward
Four ways to score have existed for the whole of NFL history: the touchdown (6 points), the kick after it (1), the field goal (3) and the safety (2). The two-point conversion joined them in 1994. The AFL used it throughout its 1960-69 run, and those games are part of the grid here.
Do the arithmetic with only touchdowns, extra points and field goals and a team can reach every total except six: 1, 2, 4, 5, 8 and 11. Everything else is some mix of 3, 6 and 7. A team that finishes on 5 kicked a field goal and got a safety. A team that finishes on 8 or 11 needed a safety or, after 1994, a two-point try.
You can see the rule change in the data. In 8,886 NFL games before 1994 (leaving the AFL out), a team ended a game with 8 points 15 times and with 11 points 10 times. In the 8,637 games since, it has happened 37 times and 49 times. The two-point conversion made those totals roughly three and a half times as common. Of the 53 scores in the grid with an 8 or an 11 on either side, 32 first appeared in 1994 or later.
Scores that needed a safety
The single most delicate result in the grid might be 5-3. The Frankford Yellow Jackets beat the New York Giants by that score on October 17, 1925, and nobody has matched it. Two field goals, one safety, nothing else.
Two years earlier, on November 25, 1923, the Racine Legion beat the Chicago Cardinals 10-4. With no two-point conversion in 1923, there is exactly one way to finish a game on 4 points: two safeties. That has also happened once.
- 2-0 has happened five times, all between 1923 and 1938. The Packers beat the Bears 2-0 in 1932, and the Bears answered with a 2-0 win over Green Bay on September 18, 1938. No NFL game has ended that way since.
- 7-5: Washington over the Detroit Lions, October 16, 1938. Once.
- 9-2 (Packers over the Cardinals, 1929) and 10-2 (the Duluth Eskimos over the Canton Bulldogs, 1926) are both one-offs.
- 8-3: the Cleveland Browns beat the Giants by that score in a playoff game on December 17, 1950. Cleveland's 8 had to include a safety.
- 11-0: the Lions over Tampa Bay on September 4, 1983. Another safety, another one-off.
- 45-2 (Rams over the Baltimore Colts, December 5, 1953) and 28-2 (Chiefs over Jacksonville, September 8, 2013) are lopsided games where the loser's only points came from a safety.
Odd numbers on the big stage
Some of these strange scores came in the games people remember best. Super Bowl XLVIII, on February 2, 2014, finished Seattle 43, Denver 8. It is the only 43-8 in league history. Seattle's first points were a safety on the opening snap, and Denver's 8 came from a touchdown and a two-point conversion, so both sides of the score lean on the rare plays.
The AFC Championship Game after the 1978 season, played January 7, 1979, ended Pittsburgh 34, Houston 5. Before 1994 the only way to make 5 was a field goal plus a safety. 34-5 has never happened again.
The NFC Championship Game on January 23, 2000, went to the St. Louis Rams, 11-6 over Tampa Bay. That score waited 23 years for a second appearance, when Miami beat the Jets 11-6 on January 8, 2023. Two other playoff games with an 11 on the losing side produced one-offs: Dallas 30, Philadelphia 11 on January 7, 1996, and Philadelphia 23, the Giants 11 on January 11, 2009.
And then there is Super Bowl XXI. The Giants beat Denver 39-20 on January 25, 1987, and 39-20 has never been seen again. Nothing about it needs a safety. It is just a score that, for whatever reason, the sport has not repeated in nearly forty years.
Blowouts and shootouts
At the other end of the grid, every one of the extremes below has happened exactly once.
| Score | Date | Winner | Loser | Why it stands out |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 73-0 | Dec 8, 1940 | Chicago Bears | Washington | 1940 NFL Championship; biggest margin ever |
| 66-0 | Oct 10, 1920 | Rochester Jeffersons | Fort Porter | Oldest one-off score in the grid |
| 64-0 | Nov 6, 1934 | Philadelphia Eagles | Cincinnati Reds | Third-largest margin |
| 62-3 | Nov 7, 1954 | Cleveland Browns | Washington | 59-point margin |
| 72-41 | Nov 27, 1966 | Washington | New York Giants | 113 points, the most in one game |
| 58-48 | Nov 28, 2004 | Cincinnati Bengals | Cleveland Browns | 106 points |
| 54-51 | Nov 19, 2018 | Los Angeles Rams | Kansas City Chiefs | Highest losing score (51) |
| 70-20 | Sep 24, 2023 | Miami Dolphins | Denver Broncos | Joint third-highest winning score |
The Bears' 73 is still the highest winning score in the grid. Washington's 72 against the Giants is one point behind it, and that game also holds the record for combined points. Miami's 70 in 2023 matched the Rams' 70-27 win over the Colts from 1950.
The 1920s are a museum
Eleven one-off scores date from the 1920s, the league's first decade. Several are safety games already mentioned. Others are blowouts that a league of evenly matched pro teams would struggle to produce, like the Akron Pros' 62-0 win over the Oorang Indians in 1922 and Frankford's 54-0 rout of the Buffalo Bisons in 1927. There is also 19-19, a tie between the Giants and the Detroit Wolverines on November 11, 1928, which nobody has matched.
The other mark of that era is how little scoring there was. 0-0 has happened 73 times, 57 of them before 1930. The last scoreless tie was the Lions and Giants on November 7, 1943. Even 7-0, which has happened 91 times, has not appeared since the Patriots beat New Orleans on December 4, 1983.
Normal-looking scores that have never happened
Ties produce some of the grid's quietest gaps. Of the 311 tied games in the data, 280 came before 1974, the year regular-season overtime arrived; only 31 have come in the 13,051 games since. That is why 9-9, 15-15, 18-18 and 22-22 are all still empty, even though 10-10 has happened 24 times. 26-26 exists exactly once (Packers and Vikings, November 24, 2013), and so does 40-40 (Cowboys and Packers, September 28, 2025).
Away from the diagonal, the most overdue score in the league is 36-23. Its neighbors are busy: 35-24 has happened 26 times, 37-24 18 times, 36-22 11 times. We took how often teams have scored each total in the 7,139 games since 2000 and treated the two sides as independent. On that rough model, 36-23 should have turned up about four times by now. It has never happened.
- 40-31: never, though 41-31 has happened 13 times.
- 20-11: never, though 20-10 has happened 126 times. The 11 needs a safety or a two-point try.
- 18-9: never, next door to 17-10, which has happened 150 times.
- 27-8: never, while 27-7 has happened 97 times.
The grid keeps moving, slowly. The 2026 season had produced three brand-new NFL scores by early November: Minnesota's 39-22 win over Green Bay and Chicago's 59-37 win over Carolina, both on September 13, and Cincinnati's 43-36 win over Tennessee on November 1. Somebody, someday, will get 36-23.