Scorigami Center

Why soccer stopped making new scores

By Scorigami Center · · 6 min read

England's top flight has been running since 1888. Count the old First Division and the Premier League that replaced it as one competition and our English top-flight grid holds 51,040 matches. Those matches have produced 51 different final scores. The most recent new one arrived on October 11, 1958, when Tottenham Hotspur beat Everton 10-4. England has played another 28,163 top-flight matches since, and not one of them added a square.

Advertisement

For a sense of scale, the NBA's 73,295 games have produced 3,191 distinct final scores and the NFL's 18,139 games have produced 1,093. Scorigami, the hunt for a final score that has never happened before, is a weekly running joke in American football. In soccer it is closer to archaeology.

Four scores do half the work

The short explanation is that soccer scores live in one small corner of the grid and pile up there. In England, 1-0 has finished 7,867 top-flight matches (15.4%). 2-1 has finished 7,254 (14.2%), 2-0 5,734 (11.2%) and 1-1 5,653 (11.1%). Those four results account for 51.9% of every match in English top-flight history.

Widen the lens to the big five European leagues together (England, Spain, Italy, Germany and France) and you get 157,364 matches with just 57 distinct final scores between them. The same four results cover 53.4% of those matches, and 25.9% of them end level.

CompetitionFromMatchesDistinct scores1-0, 2-1, 2-0, 1-1DrawsNewest score
England top flight188851,0405151.9%24.6%10-4 (1958)
La Liga192827,8245154.8%24.0%10-2 (2015)
Serie A192929,3044056.7%29.6%9-3 (1972)
Bundesliga196319,2524548.8%25.6%12-0 (1978)
Ligue 1193229,9444754.3%26.2%7-4 (1965)
Eredivisie195621,1814848.3%25.1%13-0 (2020)
Champions League19557,8704151.4%20.9%8-4 (2016)
World Cup (with qualifying)19309,8395352.3%21.3%14-0 (2019)
Euros (with qualifying)19583,2123454.9%20.4%14-0 (2023)
Copa America19161,7383646.8%21.6%11-0 (1975)
NWSL20161,6062461.4%23.1%6-3 (2023)

Serie A is the draw capital. Nearly three Italian matches in ten have finished level, and in the 1970s the figure reached 38.2%, in a decade when the league averaged 2.04 goals a game. The NWSL, the youngest league on the list, is the most concentrated of all: 61.4% of its matches land on one of the big four results.

The grid filled up almost immediately

Nearly every soccer grid follows the same arc. There is a burst of new scores in the first few seasons, then a long quiet. England logged 31 of its 51 scores before the end of 1889, and 40 of them inside its first ten years. The Bundesliga found 41 of its 45 in its first decade. Ligue 1 had 39 of its 47 before 1940.

Early football was simply higher scoring and far more lopsided. English top-flight matches in the 1880s averaged 4.55 goals, and 12.1% of them were won by five goals or more. By the 1970s those figures had dropped to 2.55 goals and 1.1%. Spain traced the same curve, from 4.18 goals a game in the 1930s to 2.47 in the 1980s. Several leagues still have their biggest wins sitting in that early chaos: West Bromwich Albion 12-0 Darwen in April 1892, or Athletic Bilbao 12-1 Barcelona in February 1931.

The long waits

Once the easy squares were claimed, new ones came decades apart, and in several leagues they stopped coming at all.

  • Ligue 1: Saint-Etienne beat Lille 7-4 on October 24, 1965. In the 21,918 matches since, France has not produced another new score.
  • Serie A: AC Milan beat Atalanta 9-3 on October 15, 1972, which is 17,172 matches ago. The same fixture had already given Italy a new 7-4 on Christmas Eve 1950.
  • Bundesliga: Borussia Monchengladbach beat Borussia Dortmund 12-0 on April 29, 1978, the last day of the 1977-78 season. Gladbach were chasing Köln for the title and lost it anyway on goal difference. Germany has gone 14,794 matches without a new score since.
  • Champions League: after Basel beat Club Brugge 6-4 in November 1973, the competition waited 33.7 years for MSK Zilina's 5-4 win over F91 Dudelange in a July 2007 qualifier. Borussia Dortmund's 8-4 over Legia Warszawa on November 22, 2016, is still the newest.
  • Copa America: Argentina beat Venezuela 11-0 on August 10, 1975. Nothing new in 954 matches since.

Then there are the two famous breaks. La Liga went 55.9 years between new scores, from Real Madrid's 11-2 over Elche in February 1960 to Real Madrid's 10-2 over Rayo Vallecano on December 20, 2015. One club bookended the entire drought. In the Netherlands, the Eredivisie waited 29.4 years after RKC Waalwijk and FC Twente drew 6-6 in June 1991, until Ajax beat VVV-Venlo 13-0 on October 24, 2020. That is the widest margin in Eredivisie history and the most recent new score in any of the six European leagues on this site.

Why the grid stopped growing

A new score needs goals, usually a lot of them, and modern top-flight soccer rarely supplies them. Since 2000 each of the big five leagues has played somewhere between 8,000 and 10,000 matches, and each has produced only 30 to 36 distinct scores in that time. Everything else on their grids was set long ago.

The other ingredient is the mismatch, and the gap between the best and worst teams in a top flight has narrowed sharply. Since 2000, the share of matches won by five or more goals is 1.05% in Serie A, 1.37% in Ligue 1, 1.82% in La Liga, 2.08% in England and 2.42% in the Bundesliga. Compare that with the 12.1% of 1880s England, or the 9.6% of 1930s Spain. Better-drilled defending and deeper squads have squeezed both ends of the grid at once: fewer goals overall, and far fewer routs.

Where genuine mismatches still exist, the grid still moves. International qualifying throws the best national teams against the smallest. In World Cup qualifying, 8.27% of matches have been won by five or more goals and 50 by ten or more. At the finals themselves the rate is 4.03%, and no finals match has ever been won by ten. Qualifying has produced 51 distinct scores in 8,771 matches, against 34 in 1,068 at the finals.

That is where the outlandish numbers live. Australia beat Tonga 22-0 on April 9, 2001, and then American Samoa 31-0 two days later, still the biggest score on any soccer grid here. Qatar beat Bhutan 15-0 in 2015 and Iran beat Cambodia 14-0 in 2019. Euro qualifying gave us Germany 13-0 San Marino in 2006, the Netherlands 11-0 San Marino in 2011 and France 14-0 Gibraltar on November 18, 2023.

Where the next one might come from

The holes are surprisingly ordinary. England's top flight has never had an 11-0, a 7-6 or a 10-2, the very score that ended Spain's drought. La Liga has never seen an 8-4. Serie A has never had an 8-3, a 7-5 or a 6-6. The Bundesliga has never had a 10-1 or a 6-6, and the Champions League has never had a 5-5. Even England's wildest modern matches land on old squares. When West Bromwich Albion and Manchester United drew 5-5 on May 19, 2013, in Sir Alex Ferguson's final match, it was the 16th 5-5 in English top-flight history. One more goal either way would have made a 6-5, a score England has now seen nine times.

If one big league is due, it is probably Germany. The Bundesliga is averaging 3.17 goals a game in the 2020s, its highest decade since the 1980s, and 3.69% of its matches this decade have been won by five or more. The NWSL is the other candidate, simply because its grid is young: 24 scores, the newest a 6-3 for the Kansas City Current over the Chicago Stars on October 8, 2023, and still no 5-3.

Until one of them breaks through, the safest bet in soccer is the one that has been safe since Queen Victoria's reign. Somebody wins 1-0.

Advertisement