Scorigami Center

The oldest final scores that have never happened again

By Scorigami Center · · 5 min read

On May 13, 1876, in the first season of the National League, the Hartford Dark Blues beat the New York Mutuals 28-3. Major League Baseball has played 236,900 games since that afternoon, counting the postseason, and not one of them has ended 28-3. Most of the leagues we track have scores like that: results that happened once, long ago, and have been sitting alone in their square of the grid ever since.

Advertisement

Scores that happened once

A one-off is easy to define. It is a final score that appears exactly once in a league's entire history. Most one-offs are recent, because a new score has to start somewhere. The interesting ones are old. They have had decades, sometimes a century and a half, to be matched, and the sport has never managed it.

Here are the oldest surviving one-offs in a selection of the leagues on the site.

LeagueScoreDateWinnerLoser
College football4-3Nov 8, 1873ColumbiaRutgers
MLB28-3May 13, 1876Hartford Dark BluesNew York Mutuals
International rugby3-1Jan 8, 1883ScotlandWales
English top flight8-5Sep 6, 1890Derby CountyBlackburn Rovers
NHL14-7Jan 10, 1920Montreal CanadiensToronto St. Patricks
Olympic hockey29-0Apr 24, 1920United StatesSwitzerland
NFL66-0Oct 10, 1920Rochester JeffersonsFort Porter
La Liga12-1Feb 8, 1931Athletic BilbaoFC Barcelona
Ligue 112-11934-35 seasonFC SochauxUS Valenciennes-Anzin
Serie A5-5Jan 12, 1941Torino FCInter
NBA63-47Nov 2, 1946Chicago StagsNew York Knicks

A few of these are famous for other reasons. The Bilbao result is still the heaviest league defeat Barcelona has suffered in our data. The Canadiens' 14-7 win produced 21 goals, a total the NHL has matched only once, when Edmonton beat Chicago 12-9 on December 11, 1985. Seven weeks after the 14-7, on March 3, 1920, the Canadiens beat the Quebec Bulldogs 16-3. Nobody in the NHL has scored 16 goals in a game since, and that score is a one-off too.

Grids that stopped growing

In some leagues the question is bigger than one old score. The whole grid has gone quiet. For years, and in most cases decades, every result in these competitions has landed on a score that had already happened.

LeagueDistinct scoresLast new scoreDateGames since
English top flight5110-4, Tottenham Hotspur over EvertonOct 11, 195828,163
Ligue 1477-4, Saint-Etienne over LilleOct 24, 196521,918
Serie A409-3, AC Milan over AtalantaOct 15, 197217,172
Copa America3611-0, Argentina over VenezuelaAug 10, 1975954
Bundesliga4512-0, Gladbach over DortmundApr 29, 197814,794
NHL9513-1, Calgary over San JoseFeb 10, 199340,892
NPB (Japan)22322-6, Softbank over OrixMay 24, 20169,216
MLB33024-8, San Diego over WashingtonJul 16, 202113,462

England's grid is the most striking. The top flight has played 51,040 matches since 1888 and produced only 51 different scores. The last new one was 10-4, Tottenham over Everton on October 11, 1958, which was also Bill Nicholson's first match as Spurs manager. More than 28,000 matches later, nothing new.

The Bundesliga's last new score is its most famous. Borussia Monchengladbach beat Borussia Dortmund 12-0 on the final day of the 1977-78 season. It is still the biggest win in Bundesliga history and Dortmund's heaviest defeat, and it was not enough: Cologne took the title on goal difference.

Why the early years filled the grid

The pattern is the same nearly everywhere. A league's first seasons do most of the work, and then the grid fills more and more slowly. Some numbers from the data:

  • English football: 31 of the 51 scores first appeared in the top flight's opening two seasons, which contained just 264 matches. Those two seasons averaged 4.53 goals a game. The 1970s averaged 2.54.
  • The NHL: 51 of its 95 scores appeared in the league's first three seasons (1917-18 to 1919-20), when games averaged 8.89 goals.
  • MLB: 160 of its 330 scores appeared between 1876 and 1879, a span of 945 games, when teams combined for about 11 runs a game. By the 1900s that was down to 7.98. Of the 330, 299 had appeared before 1900.
  • Serie A, Ligue 1 and the Eredivisie each found three quarters or more of their scores in their first three seasons: 30 of 40, 36 of 47 and 37 of 48.

Part of this is simple: the first games of any league fill empty squares because every square is empty. But the old games were also built differently. Early baseball was played with few or no fielding gloves, and the run totals show it. The Chicago Colts' 36-7 win over Louisville on June 29, 1897, is still the most runs one team has scored in our MLB data. Early football clubs lined up with five forwards, and the gap between the best and worst teams in a league could be enormous. Both 12-goal winning margins in English top-flight history came before 1910: West Bromwich Albion's 12-0 over Darwen in 1892 and Nottingham Forest's 12-0 over Leicester City in 1909.

Hockey is the clearest case of a sport changing under the scoreboard. The NHL grid filled twice: once in its wild first seasons, and again in the high-scoring 1980s, when games averaged 7.61 goals and 2,163 of them reached double figures combined. Seven new scores arrived that decade. Then came one more, Calgary's 13-1 over the San Jose Sharks in 1993, and nothing since in more than 40,000 games.

The NBA's lost box scores

Basketball has so many possible scores that its grid never freezes, but it still carries a frozen corner. The 1946-47 season, the first in NBA history, produced 60 of the league's 645 one-off scores. The lowest-scoring game in NBA history comes from that era too: the Fort Wayne Pistons beat the Minneapolis Lakers 19-18 on November 22, 1950.

The shot clock arrived for the 1954-55 season, and you can see it in the data. Games averaged 159.4 combined points in 1953-54 and 186.7 the next year. Every season before the clock left behind one-off scores, 157 of them in total. The 1954-55 season left none. Scores in the 50s and 60s, like the Washington Capitols' 50-33 win over the Detroit Falcons on November 2, 1946, now belong to a different sport. Last season, 2025-26, games averaged 230.2 points.

Which frozen grid thaws first

The youngest freeze is the most fragile. MLB's last two new scores came close together, Atlanta's 29-9 win over Miami in 2020 and San Diego's 24-8 over Washington in 2021, so one bad night for a pitching staff could add another. The soccer grids are a different story. The smallest score England's top flight has never produced is 11-0, and every other gap needs at least 12 goals. Serie A, Ligue 1 and the Bundesliga are in the same position: none of them is missing anything with fewer than 11 goals. The Hartford Dark Blues' 28-3, meanwhile, will turn 151 next May.

Advertisement